Sunday, December 11, 2011

Universal Truths About the Citizen's Role in Great Governance: The Importance of Reason


I didn't go into reading this book expecting to get out of it what I did. And there's more to it than just valuable stuff about civic engagement. (For the record, it's a badly-edited effort lacking in focus...and too often an unseemly and overwrought polemic against President George W. Bush.)

But as I was reading it, I came across some powerful bits, and I want to share them with you, because what Town Halls Hamilton is all about is very much what this stuff is all about. 


So herein are some choice excerpts...with some comments from me, as suitable.

(Fair warning: In most instances, I've paraphrased Mr. Gore's words. As little as possible, retaining the intent and the flavour of the material, but mostly excising American references. The propositions' value certainly take up a space well above and beyond the borders of the US, so I've taken the liberty to revise as necessary.)

Tuesday, November 29, 2011

Followup to Councillor Farr's Evening, Part Two

While I don't yet have the long-promised answers to all the questions that weren't gotten to at 'An Evening With Ward 2 Councillor Jason Farr', the councillor has posted links to the 'rough notes' for his responses that night:




The Spec Letter #2


CHML's Scott Thompson has an op-ed piece in today's Spec. Entitled 'Does Canada need to be Occupied?', it raises some interesting questions. 

Here's what I sent off to Mr. Thompson:

The Spec Letter #1


The main editorial in today's Spec by Robert Howard, 'Is Hamilton a hard place to do business?' prompted me to write a letter to him:

Tuesday, November 22, 2011

Followup to Councillor Farr's Evening, Part One



In ancipation of the answers forthcoming from Ward 2 Councillor Jason Farr, here is the list of questions compiled from the six neighbourhood associations. 

Wednesday, November 16, 2011

Meanwhile, over at the F.U.N...




Earlier this autumn, I made contact with one of the most extraordinary people I've had the pleasure of meeting since taking this 'town halls' notion out of my head and pushing it out into the real world. 


Her name is Janice Brown, and she looks after Communications at the Federation of Urban Neighbourhoods. But she's also on the Durand Neighbourhood Association's Board of Directors. 

From the start of our correspondence, through our coffee face-to-face, the lead-up to our inaugural town hall and post-event, Janice was helpful and encouraging. I'm so glad synchronicity was at play throughout. And I'm glad there are Janice Browns out there helping to steward the needs of our community and neighbourhood associations. 

Here's a guest article I contributed to their newsletter.  (A special shout-out to my brother, who gave some editorial input when I was faffing about.)

Friday, November 11, 2011

The Morning After The Night Before: Post-inaugural Town Hall Blues


Preface/disclaimer: The opinions and viewpoints that follow are mine and mine alone. Were you to speak to anyone connected to 'An Evening With Ward 2 Councillor Jason Farr', or more importantly, those at the event who proffered opinions, the consensus would be something quite different. In the words of THH stalwart -and RTH contributor- Mike Borrelli, '107 people went out for coffee during Intermission. 102 came back. That is astounding.' More importantly, none of my 'disappointments' have anything to do with what any of the volunteers contributed. They rocked, and I am especially grateful for the time and efforts they provided.

To have a 'vision' –and I'm referring to an ambition or a goal, though the other meaning of the word surely has some connection here– is to be possessed of some singular expectations. And while these expectations might seem quite reasonable to the person having them, when these expectations don't get met, they may not get classified as 'failures' to others. I can't take issue with this. But then the Town Halls Hamilton endeavour has been my vision from the start, so I'm allowed to be disgruntled about how things turned out last night. 

As the Robert Burns quote goes, "The best laid schemes o' mice an' men / Gang aft agley."

Post-event, Part Two

Because things didn't play out as planned (!!!), because we ran out of time, because I'd already felt I'd compromised the evening's effectiveness, I didn't force my closing comments on everyone last night. Here then, is what I'd intended on saying:




You don’t play sports to get in shape. You get in shape to play sports
That piece of sage advice was provided by a family doctor and family friend ages ago. And its wisdom is just as solid now as it was then, four decades in the past.
I believe the same can be said for effecting change within your neighbourhood, your community, your city: you don’t dive into substantive, contentious issues in the hope that you can generate civic engagement. You generate civic engagement so that you’re better equipped to address substantive, contentious issues when they begin to unfold.
About 15 months ago, I was having an email correspondence with Ryan McGreal, the editor of ‘Raise The Hammer’. 
We had been discussing the upcoming municipal election and I’d asked the question ‘What do you think voters should be looking for in new candidates this autumn?
Ryan’s answer was thorough, but what struck me was a particular portion: 
“...it's so important for citizens to: a) elect councillors who will allow themselves to be engaged, and b) keep up their end of that engagement between elections.”
It’s a sentiment I certainly hadn’t seen pushed in media, and it resonated with me. 
To the extent that all this time later, we’ve gathered here in this room for a town hall meeting. 
Soon after this exchange with Ryan, a notion coalesced that has pretty much remained intact. It’s the core of what Town Halls Hamilton is attempting to achieve:
“To increase the relationship of engagement between residents and their Councillors.”
It’s important that the direction of this sentiment is appreciated: the focus is on the relationship between residents and their Councillors. Not the other way around. This may seem to be quibbling, but as they say, ‘God is in the details.’
I’d hoped that what might result from tonight’s town hall meeting is a burbling sense of possibility. So that’s my wish for you all post-event: possibility. 
I believe that 2012 is going to be an exciting year in Hamilton. For the residents of Hamilton, for the citizens of this city. And Town Halls Hamilton will be attempting to play its part; we’re planning to produce a full slate of events, a mix of both ward-specific town halls as well as issue-specific ones. Here’s a short sampling of potential topics for that latter category:
-Local Governance: What Do We Owe Each Other?
-Walkability/Rideability Hamilton
-Poverty
-Aerotropolis
-Dream a Little Dream; What Downtown Could Be
-Speakers’ Corner, Squared
-Is Hamilton Really Open for Business?
A quick thanks to Mahesh Butani for providing consistent encouragement along the way, sustained thanks to Mike Borelli for his impassioned input throughout the run-up to tonight, grateful thanks to our energetic and effervescent moderator, Stephanie Seagram...and respectful thanks to our special guest, Ward 2 Councillor Farr who had faith in our abilities to craft the kind of interlude that respects all those involved, as well as honouring the process of local governance. 
Most of all, thanks to you for joining us for this inaugural Town Halls Hamilton event. 
Good night, everyone. 

Post-event, Part One



My gratitude to those who attended last night's 'An Evening With Ward 2 Councillor Farr', numbering over a hundred.

And my apologies to the same for not delivering what I had intended...and promised. Mea culpa, lessons learned and all that. (To say I've felt vexed or humbled would be an understatement.)

As for the wealth of questions-asked that were not presented (never mind answered), I should have news on the fulfillment of this commitment soon. 

Tuesday, November 8, 2011

As 'An Evening With Ward 2 Councillor Jason Farr' approaches...



'Town halls aim to battle cynicism' is the latest offering from The Spec. We invite you to take a look.

Regarding Neighbourhood Associations...

As I'd had an unusual number of conversations of late about NAs, specifically asking the question 'How are they recognized by the City?', while I was at City Hall this morning, getting things prepped for the event on Thursday night, I asked some questions.

Basically, it's up to the ward Councillor to vet the group. Once that's been done, once it's clear to their satisfaction that the group represents the people in the area, which might include a petition, or a meeting, then the recommendation is passed-on to the Planning Department. Then it gets added to the afore-linked 'Neighbourhood Association Directory'.


Easy-peasy, lemon-squeezy.  

Monday, November 7, 2011

Altogether now...

Everything about Town Halls Hamilton is about engagement.

And to me, when there's broad-based engagement, there's synergy, there's confluence, there's the possibility of reaching some pretty astounding critical mass...often resulting in stuff that might never have been imagined previously.

I've met Joey Coleman, the man behind much of this 'open' movement in Hamilton, and I'm proud to say that he supports our efforts, just as we do his.

To that end, check out this post

(Thanks to Larry Pattison for passing along this update.) 

Saturday, November 5, 2011

Guest Editorial

Recently I received a very nice email from Joshua Weresch. It was one of the more pleasant elements of congruence, serendipity and synchronicity I've experienced of late. 

We got together last week before a meeting of the Central Neighbourhood Association, had a long conversation over coffee. After which Joshua stuck around for the meeting, even though he doesn't live in the Central area. Or Ward 2, for that matter. Or even in Hamilton; he lives on The Mountain. (I'm allowed this age-old joke.)

Charmed by his enthusiasm, I asked him if he wanted to write a guest piece for Town Halls Hamilton. Here then, is Joshua's article.


     Adrian asked me to write about my incipient community engagement journey. So, as I've found stories of engagement to be encouraging to me, I hope you find this tale to be worth its reading, a reminder that engagement is not a journey to be walked alone.  

      I'm a life-long Hamiltonian. I grew up on the west Mountain, on the corner of Upper Paradise Road and Scenic Drive, next door to the former Beckers convenience store. Growing up, our neighbours were folks we saw out and about occasionally: next door, a Lithuanian family; across the street, a Dutch family; and a few houses down, school-teachers of my brother and me. It was a quiet neighbourhood, punctuated now and again, by the screams of children in swimming-pools and the rattle of lawn-mowers starting up, and fiercely sub-urban. There were in me, few civic or political noises to make: I sometimes voted, sometimes didn't, but, especially in local politics, when I did, it was a thoughtless process at best.

      How did I get- Better, how am I getting, because I'm certainly not there just yet, from 'thoughtless' to 'thoughtful', from an inconsiderate life to a considerate one? Where is this drive for civic engagement coming from? 


     I think that it began a few years ago with a couple of incidents and has continued to press on me since then. Two or three years ago, my wife and I moved into the neighbourhood of Centremount. I put out the garbage one night, and with it, a couple of cases of empties. The next morning, I saw an old, bearded man on a bicycle, with blue recycling bags balanced on the handles, going from bin to bin and taking out the empties for the ten-cent refund from The Beer Store. I thought to myself, “What the heck is he doing in the suburbs?” That was the first incident, a pricking of conscience, uneasiness. 

     The second incident came when my wife and I saw older men and women, who used to visit at Mountain Plaza Mall, try to get across Fennell Avenue with their walkers and bags as traffic dodged and weaved around them. My wife said to me, “Why isn't there a cross-walk for pedestrians there? They're going to get killed.” Poverty in the suburbs and the difficulties of older people started up the rattling motor.

      Now I have a daughter almost one year old and I wonder what kind of world she'll inherit. I wonder what kind of world any of our family will have. Will it even be 'kind'? Is it going to be a world where people don't care or know about one another? Is it going to be a world that requires of her courage to get outside, know, and help another person, to have meaningful relationships? At the ripe age of thirty years, I'm beginning to see the importance of relationships in the place in which we live. If we're going to live here, if we're going to call this place home, work and play with my daughter and family in this city, then why shouldn't I want to make this place the best that I can?

      Now I'm taking steps toward getting a neighbourhood association together for Centremount. It'll mean knocking on plenty of doors, as there are, according to Statistics Canada, 1,730 private dwellings in the neighbourhood and a minimum of 3,883 people to meet. The Ward 7 neighbourhoods of Eleanor, Eastmount, and Allison Park already have community councils and other neighbourhoods in this ward have had councils that have come and gone, too. I think it's a good start: instead of complaining about the neighbourhood, it'd be good, I think, to have a place, a bunch of good people, to bring those complaints to; also, it'd be good to be able to talk and get to know one another, just so we don't feel so isolated from one another. We'll have a way of making changes in our neighbourhood, so people can safely cross a street, so all ages are cared for and respected, not reduced. 

     The distance between fear and love is, I think, the distance from my front porch to an old man –whose name I don't even know –who's collecting empties from my recycling bin.

Friday, November 4, 2011

The second in a series...




Over at Raise the Hammer, we have an ongoing series of neighbourhood profiles leading up to next week's 'An Evening With Ward 2 Councillor Jason Farr' in Council Chambers at City Hall.

Second up is North End Neighbours

Check out the article here.

Thursday, November 3, 2011

...but then, they're not supposed to be the same animal...


Tonight I spent an hour at Ward 4 Councillor Sam Merulla's community meeting at Pat Quinn Arena. The room was packed; I'd guess there were about twenty-five people, not including a trio of City Hall staff (Landscape Architect Cynthia Graham was especially effective during her Cown Point East Neighbourhood Plan presentation. Well done, Ms Graham!) and three (?) law enforcement officers of various genres, as well as at least a couple of other people there to provide input and information.

A 'community meeting' isn't a 'town hall', but then as the title of this post insists, they're not supposed to be. The structure of tonight's get-together was an item-by-item presentation with questions allowed at appropriate times. (The itinerary can be found here.)

It was nicely choreographed by Councillor Merulla, allowing for just enough discussion, moving things along when it was clear there was a likelihood that things might get mired, suggesting how an issue might be expedited, providing appropriate context and perspective...

As I said, I was only able to stay for an hour, but my reaction was simple: it was heartening to see democracy in action, to see involvement and participation by the residents, to have people in the same room talking things through. (Well, for the most part 'talking things through'...)

Hats off to Councillor Merulla for this effective community meeting. Here's to hoping he'll consider working with us in the new year. 

Wednesday, November 2, 2011

The first in a series...


Over at Raise the Hammer, we have an ongoing series of neighbourhood profiles leading up to next week's 'An Evening With Ward 2 Councillor Jason Farr' in Council Chambers at City Hall.


Check out the article here.

Tuesday, November 1, 2011

If you're from Ward 2...

...and even if you're not...

The agenda for the November 10th event at City Hall Council Chambers 'An Evening With Ward 2 Councillor Jason Farr' will be almost exclusively determined by questions and issues submitted by residents of the six neighbourhood associations and/or attendees that night.

Additionally, if there's something you'd like to see addressed, a contentious issue, or even one that's benign, please consider sending it to townhallshamilton@gmail.com

Sunday, October 30, 2011

Two non-Town Hall Offerings

This site is about town halls in Hamilton. However, seeing as the underlying theme is 'engagement', it's occasionally going to make sense for there to be links and features that might not specifically connect to the notion of town halls...but are certainly important factors and influences and notions to consider. 

On this occasion, I have two things to offer, and both feature Toronto 'community choreographer' Dave Meslin, co-editor of the book 'Local Motion: The Art of Civic Engagement in Toronto'. 


The first is from the launch event for '3 Things for Calgary', the kind of initiative that's indicative of genuine visionary leadership. (I'll have more to say about this anon, this idea that not all the emphasis for authentic forward movement should come from City Hall, that inspiration must be a two-way street, with each portion of the previously-mentioned 'great governance formula' –residents and Councillors– possessed of both transmitters and receivers, an endless –and endlessly-empowering– loop)



The second is a TED talk given by Mr. Meslin. The title of his presentation? 'The Antidote to Apathy'.





M Adrian Brassington

Saturday, October 29, 2011

Observations En Route


"Most people arrive at tortured conclusions via blind and painful routes. They don't like it when someone shows up in a balloon. You can't expect anyone to trust revelation if they haven't experienced it themselves. Those who haven't, only know reason. And since revelation is a thing apart, and cannot be accounted for reasonably, they will never believe you. This is the great division of the world, and always has been. Now, when reason and revelation run together, why, then you have something, a great age. But in this city, now, reason is predominant. To argue from any other point of view or by any other means, is subversive."

Thursday, October 27, 2011

Great News!


Our November 10th event, 'An Evening With Ward 2 Councillor Jason Farr' will be streamed live online...with the chat feature. 

I guess that now means we have a potential audience...

...of billions

The Great Governance Formula

Click image to enlarge
Previously, I've referred to the idea of a 'formula' involving residents and their elected officials. I'd been thinking about it recently and realized that I hadn't really nailed the concept very well. Because I'm not a mathematics-type person, I'd unconsciously had the two elements on either side of the '=' sign. But that's not the case at all. They're both on one side, with 'Governance' on the other. 

What's all the more important, and I threw this out for consideration at last night's Hamilton Civic League meeting, is this:

At any given time, the 'Councillors' portion is delivering an average of about 75% of potential. There are always some stinky incidents and there are sometimes some interludes of excellence. 

But where the citizenry are concerned...

Wearing my 'Chapeau de Cynisme', I'd say that Hamilton's down on the low end of the 'Potential' scale. Maybe around 20, 25%? (I know that Those Who Are Active will undoubtedly rail at me for this suggestion. But I calls 'em as I sees 'em.)

Do I find this depressing? 

Nope. 

I take enormous solace in considering how much potential we have at our fingertips. 




M Adrian Brassington

Press Release

           


FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE:
Contact: M Adrian Brassington
Organization: Town Halls Hamilton
Email Address: townhallshamilton@gmail.com
Hamilton, ON, October 27th, 2011 —Town Halls Hamilton (THH) in partnership with the Hamilton Civic League (HCL) is pleased to announce its moderator for the November 10th event at City Hall in Council Chambers, ‘An Evening With Ward 2 Councillor Jason Farr’, Stephanie Seagram. 


(Photo credit: Lee Hillman/Hillman Media)
Ms Seagram is Program Director for the Cossart Exchange, a local business incubator for the creative industry and an aspect of the Imperial Cotton Centre for the Arts. As well, Stephanie has been working with people in education and development for over 15 years, has BA in Visual Arts, a Master's of Science in Education and is a member of the Ontario College of Teachers (OCT). Combined with her background are her talents as contributor to Cable 14’s For the Record.
Town Halls Hamilton Founder M Adrian Brassington said of Ms Seagram’s joining the THH team: “Stephanie brings to the effort the poise, intelligence and spirit required to make our town halls distinct experiences for guests on both sides of the stage, the Councillors and the audience. I believe she’ll prove to be the right person at the right time, the perfect addition to our endeavours.”
The Hamilton Civic League is a broad-based, non-partisan association formed in 2009 to encourage citizen engagement and involvement in the political process. Town Halls Hamilton is a nascent, grassroots endeavour to create concerted, city-wide opportunities for increased engagement between residents and their Councillors. Both organizations believe in the importance of residents being in a position of greater ownership of their local governance.
For additional information, contact M Adrian Brassington at townhallshamilton@gmail.com or visit http://townhallshamilton.blogspot.com/
# # #



Wednesday, October 19, 2011

Speaking of engagement...

In today's Spec, there's a great letter, 'If people are engaged, then they'll vote'. In it, the writer presents some meaty material, stuff that's worth considering...if contentious. You can click the link, but I'm also publishing it here (with emphasis being mine): 


Voter turnout
I have read with interest the discussion that followed the provincial election regarding the low level of voter participation. One theme has been the general distaste with the lack of choice, and this feeling also often crops up in class discussion at McMaster University where I am a student in political science.
I have to ask how many of the people who feel this way are members of a political party, where anyone can have a significant effect on the candidates and policies that are put forward? How many regularly write letters to the editor, or contact their MPs and the various cabinet ministers, and so make their views known? And how many have more than the superficial understanding of the issues that simply following the headlines and TV news provides? From discussions on the street and from polls, it is evident that many or most people don’t.
I do not support any limitations on the right to vote, but until people are willing to fulfil their democratic responsibility to understand the issues, perhaps it isn’t necessarily desirable that they do vote. Our political culture will not change until our civic culture does, with people becoming more engaged. Until then, politicians will continue to pander to populist feelings with misleading rhetoric.

Liam Helder, Hamilton

Tuesday, October 18, 2011

If Wishing Made It So...

Under different circumstances, I'd love to have rolled out Town Halls Hamilton events by now. Here then, is my Top Six Topics list for issue-specific town halls we'd have presented over the past few months...'if wishing made it so':

Monday, October 17, 2011

Back to Where it All Began


The impetus behind Town Halls Hamilton began on my 'original' community activism blog, My Stoney Creek.

In July of 2010, as we approached the Municipal Election, I posted this editorial. So in a very real sense, what you see here, began there.

Shortly after this was published, I felt compelled to really dig into the subject of 'engagement', and wrote a five-part series taking a thorough (some would say 'exhaustive', others might prefer 'exhausting') look at the notion. Here then, are links to the My Stoney Creek essays 'The Great Political 'Engagement' Conundrum:

Part One


Part Two


Part Three


Part Four


Part Five



M Adrian Brassington

Sunday, October 16, 2011

Variations on a Theme

A question I consistently get asked about how Town Halls Hamilton intends to pursue its goals is "What are the town halls going to be about?'

My primary answer is 'Whatever the organizing neighbourhood association decides in collaboration with their Councillor.' 

My secondary answer has to do with non ward-specific town halls. 

There are myriad topics that go beyond the immediate concerns of any particular neighbourhood association or ward. Concerns that transcend all 'borders' or community constructs. We're planning on promoting these events just as heartily as the ward-specific town halls, even though they'll undoubtedly consist of more than just our Moderator and a guest on stage. 

Friday, October 14, 2011

From over at Raise The Hammer...


Please take a look at this article, tying in with yesterday's press release of the partnership between the Hamilton Civic League and Town Halls Hamilton.

Thursday, October 13, 2011

Press Release


          




FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE:

Contact: Larry Pomerantz
Organization: Hamilton Civic League
Telephone Number: (905) 545-5577
Web site: http://WeVote.ca/

Hamilton, ON, October 13th, 2011 —The Hamilton Civic League (HCL) is pleased to
announce a working partnership with Town Halls Hamilton (THH) to organize and
facilitate a series of citizen-led Town Halls. Beginning with an inaugural Town Hall on
November 10th in Council Chambers at Hamilton City Hall, HCL and THH are planning
to hold similar events around the city over 2011 and 2012 to forge stronger links
between citizens and their elected representatives. With an agenda driven by local
neighbourhood associations, the Town Halls Hamilton initiative aims to bring together
civically-minded residents in a friendly, positive and constructive environment.

The Hamilton Civic League is a broad-based, non-partisan association formed in 2009
to encourage citizen engagement and involvement in the political process. Town Halls
Hamilton is a nascent, grassroots endeavour to create concerted, city-wide
opportunities for increased engagement between residents and their Councillors. Both
organizations believe in the importance of residents being in a position of greater
ownership of their local governance, and this alignment is seen as one way of building
energy and momentum towards this goal.

HCL Chair, Larry Pomerantz states “We have recently seen an increase in the number
of new organizations that share our goal to heighten civic engagement. We encourage
individuals to join and organizations to partner with HCL to forge collaborative
community building opportunities such as with Town Halls Hamilton.”

The Hamilton Civic League will be actively involved in making the Town Halls Hamilton
events successes, and the organization invites all Hamiltonians to become involved in
the initiative over the following year.

For additional information, contact Larry Pomerantz at